Photo: Belmont High School wins its third consecutive MIAA Div. 1 Girls’ Rugby state championship in June, 2023

By Kara Banosian, Matt Garver, David Lind, Katherine Oates, Sara Townsend, and Lucinda Zuniga

Can you imagine Belmont High School without sports teams?

Seriously, try to picture that. There would be no Thanksgiving Day football game against Watertown. No more boys and girls rugby dynasties. There would not be baseball, basketball, ice hockey, soccer, lacrosse, or field hockey teams — or a marching band playing at Harris Field on Friday nights. For that matter, “Soccer Night in Belmont” would vanish, along with its 2,500 spectators.

That’s the prospect Belmont faces if the override on the April 2 ballot does not pass. Without a Yes vote, all sports teams are slated to disappear from the high school within two years, a victim of the drastic budget cuts the town will face. While all other towns play on, Belmont would be sidelined. When it comes to sports, this would be Belmont’s biggest loss ever.

This possibility has become increasingly clear in recent months, and has been made explicit at numerous public meetings of the town government. At the town’s February 8 budget summit, Dr. Jill Geiser, Belmont’s Superintendent of Schools, presented a plan to deal with the massive looming cuts to the schools. If the override fails, then among many other things, all 9th grade sports, plus the ski team, would be cut for the 2024-25 school year. Then all sports teams would be cut for the 2025-26 school year.

Sports is not being singled out in this scenario. Many AP classes and electives would get slashed from the Belmont High School curriculum, along with a huge portion of other extracurricular activities. Burbank Elementary, currently ranked sixth in the state by U.S. News & World Report, would close after the 2024-25 school year. Teachers would be let go across the district. It is a grim picture, and there are still $1.2 million in school cuts left unassigned.

There are many reasons dropping sports from BHS would be painful. Sports have been shown to be great for the physical and mental well-being of participants. Even one year on a 9th grade team can spark friendships that last through high school and beyond. Indeed, we contend that dropping 9th-grade teams alone would significantly hurt BHS students. As Belmont residents in the ice hockey community, we hope kids will always have the opportunity to play for their high school, at any level.

Then there’s the sheer excitement that BHS sports builds in our community. Remember the 2020 run to the (shared) state title for the boys hockey team? How about the 2019 basketball team playing a state semifinal at the TD Garden? The BHS games and teams are part of what makes Belmont a close-knit place, and losing the BHS sports teams would tear at the fabric of the community.

Belmont High School has a proud sports history. Just look at all the banners in the fieldhouse. Some of this history involves famous athletes: Wilbur Wood, a 20-game winner as a big-league pitcher in the 1970s, was a Belmont High star in the early 1960s. But every Belmont team that competes well is a source of pride to its players and coaches. We need to keep that tradition intact.

A few times in recent weeks, we’ve heard people ask if Belmont High School could continue to play sports as long as the teams were privately funded. That’s very unlikely.

For starters, school districts must register for sports with the Massachusetts Interscholastic Athletic Association (MIAA) in the spring prior to the next academic year, guaranteeing it has funding for the full range of sports teams it submits to the MIAA.

Therefore, any private funds would have to be raised many months in advance of the following season — but even that raises more questions. Who would get to be on a team? The children of those who can donate? How would a school hire and retain good coaches with such year-to-year uncertainty? Even if a few dedicated parents raised large sums in advance for a few sports over a few years, what happens when that cohort of parents loses interest? One of the best things a high school sports program offers is stability and continuity. Any alternative would lead to chaos.

To be clear, school cuts are hardly the only thing on the ballot on April 2. A failed override would lead to deep cuts in the fire department, senior services, library access, and could lead the town to charge for trash pickup starting in 2025.

Still, even if BHS sports are just one part of this picture, they are an important part to many Belmontians. Please vote Yes on Question 1 on April 2, to avoid a profound loss for our community.